To do this, pause the game and bring up the menu. Thankfully, you can return and replay any mission you’ve completed even hours or days after it’s done. That kind of grind should be left for after the story has played out and there are no more surprises in store. While this might appeal to some, I’ve found grinding for gold ratings on a first play through breaks immersion. If they didn’t get a gold rating, they have the option to replay it right then and there. Once a player has completed a quest they’ll be given the chance to review their rating. Below is an explanation of how you can replay previously completed missions and quests in Red Dead Redemption 2. Each one will give you a bronze, silver, or gold rating based on your performance, and players can return to any mission to try and improve their rating by meeting its requirements.
Red Dead Redemption 2 takes a similar approach as Grand Theft Auto V when it comes to missions and quests.